Planting that garden
Anna wrote that square foot gardening isn’t working for her and she is going back to regular rows. Instead of clogging up her comments I decided to post my thoughts here. I had posted some of my own research earlier. Andrea commented that her family loved potatoes and would up the amount. I agree. Please feel free to add any comments or ideas.
I wasn’t too surprised that the square foot garden as presented didn’t work out. Somewhere or other I had read that it works best for small & suburban gardeners but not for those who are trying to grow as much of their own food as possible. What larger gardeners need is an adaptation. In helping Dad with his garden & my own efforts over the years, I have found this to be very true. I think the mixed beds are just too hard to keep up with. Single plantings work better.
The handiest book for me has been “Down to Earth Gardening: Know-how for the 90’s: Vegetables and Herbs” by Dick Raymond (Better known for “The Joy of Gardening”). Combined with Dad’s directions and other reading (John Jevon off the top of my head) here are my suggestions.
English peas are a pain. If you want to grow them, then do a block planting a la Raymond. Till, broadcast seeds, rake in, water. Pick by sitting on a stool and working your way through the patch. Missed ones eventually become dried peas for soup.
Personally I had my best luck with peas by growing snow peas. Then second grade son, year old son, and I went out (extremely pregnant) in February to our untilled garden. - took a hoe and chopped/sliced two very shallow & very short rows and planted seeds. Some of the seeds were not even buried but by then my back was demanding union talks so we went inside. It snowed. About the beginning of April we were picking a good bowl full every other day. No trellis, no fertilizer, no nothing but lots of snow peas.
Green beans - Dad plants dble rows & so do I. Mark out your first row and trench with the hoe, then move over about 2/3 inches and do another. Plant seeds in a zig-zag if you can & feel like it. This works good if kids are helping as you and one helper can plant on row/side and another kid can plant the other side. Because the rows are only 2/3 inches apart talking & supervision can happen without a lot of hassle - same for weeding & picking . Everything is easily supervised. Or if you are by your lonely - easily plant both yourself. Same amount of weeding & hoeing but twice the beans. When the beans are done it is easy to plant a second crop as two dble rows will leave enough space for most other crops.
My beds have been either defined by old wooden window frames (used for holding plastic) or just by flowers at either end. The frames let the kids know right where to walk - very handy. The width varies as needed - narrower for smaller things & wider for larger. I tried this with lettuce mix, onions, radishes, and carrots. It works great. What would have been a 15/20 foot row took up about 2/3 feet. Weeding was easier - kind of. But the soil was not packed down on both sides so things did have better soil to grow in. My garden is pretty small & I’ve been trying other ideas so haven’t done the lettuces again but will at the new place. Radishes I now put around anything as they are done so soon.
I also do the beds with just the flowers at the ends for peppers, eggplants, and cabbages. They are planted in a triangle/opposite triangle pattern. Same idea as the beans - saves space, weeding time, and water. I may plant one other thing with them but keep them a single item. The prettiest bed I ever had was a combination of eggplants & zinias. The eggplant that year grew over five feet tall as did the zinias. The eggplant hid the ugly bottoms that zinias get and the flowers looked wonderful in all that green. It was also my best eggplant year. I think the flowers lured more pollinators but that is just my humble opinion.
I try to do tomatoes in a ‘bed’ but not the triangle pattern, just staggered. Actually, the garden is so small that all my tomato patch is planted close and staggered. I have about 30 cages made of concrete re-enforcing wire & held in place with rebar rods. A tall cage will tip over in a good wind. The space in the squares lets us pick easily. And if we ever need to do a concrete project part of the materials are being stored right in plain sight.
A good layer of newspaper & straw really helps with the weeds. However, this year straw & hay were hard to come by so by the time I found any it never got around to putting it down. I need to mow or weedwack but haven’t. I have 36 tomatoes in there now if I could just get watering down…
Some things just need rows - corn, potatoes (but I want to try the barrel idea), vine things, okra. Cucumbers on fencing in a row, but not chicken wire. The cucumbers will grow into the wire & its a pain to pick. Cattle panels…
My biggest problems (besides bugs) are weeding & watering. I have so little space that I can not leave room for the tiller between them or I would lose half the garden. The newspaper & straw works great for everything we have tried but getting them down while planting is important. Do Not Wait For Later. This year finding straw or hay was a *major* problem.
As for watering, I have a bad habit of listening to the weather report and thinking it will rain tomorrow/next day so hold off on watering. Baaad girl….it seems to rain all around us every year. So I’m going to calendar the day/s to water and just do it. And try to weed some everyday. Yes, I know - the best laid plans…
Cindy at Big Momma Hollers is gardening in Georgia. She has been fighting drought for two years now but is harvesting bucketfuls. Her secret: wood chips. I love reading about her food harvest lists. She plants heirloom seeds too. Someday I hope to be as successful in my garden.
Cindy Adds:
It’s not just the wood chips, it’s also the manure, leaves, compost, grass clippings and everything else I’ve added over the years.
I knew that from reading her for forever (it seems) but Little Missey was trying to help type that last paragraph & I was trying to wind it up. I’m glad she added so now ya know!
Right now that is my .02 worth. How about yours?











